All top stories · This edition

Lindsay Clancy Murder Trial Ends in Mistrial; Judge Judy Warns of Danger

September 18, 2026

Summary

The murder trial of Lindsay Clancy, accused of killing her three children, ended in a mistrial after a holdout juror had no doubt she deliberately killed them. Judge Judy Sheindlin warned of the "danger" in not retrying Clancy, while a retired judge noted psychosis evidence changed everything in a similar case.

How coverage differs

Left outlets emphasize the emotional impact of Patrick Clancy's grief, while right outlets focus on Judge Judy's legal warning and his new wife's defense.

  • Left: Father's enduring grief and connection to lost children Left-leaning outlets focus on the emotional impact of the tragedy, highlighting Patrick Clancy's grief and his efforts to stay connected to his deceased children. They emphasize the personal toll and the family's perspective on the events.
  • Center: Juror's unwavering conviction: Mother deliberately killed her children Center outlets report factually on the mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy case, noting that a holdout juror had no doubt she deliberately killed her children. They provide details about the trial's outcome without taking a side on guilt or innocence.
  • Right: Judge warns of danger; husband's new wife defends him Right-leaning outlets center on the legal ramifications of the mistrial, featuring Judge Judy's strong warning about the 'danger' of not retrying Lindsay Clancy. They also highlight Patrick Clancy's new wife's defense of him against 'twisted' attacks.

Coverage by lane

Left

  • Patrick Clancy says he still speaks to his children to "stay connected to them"
  • Patrick Clancy's wife: "I don't understand how the story's been so twisted"

Center

  • Lindsay Clancy holdout juror had no doubt she deliberately killed her children

Right

  • Patrick Clancy’s new wife throws her support behind husband, rips ‘so twisted’ attacks against him
  • Judge Judy warns of 'danger' if prosecutors don't retry Lindsay Clancy after murder trial ends in mistrial

More from this edition

  • Gunman Kills 3 Students, Dies in Philippines School Shooting
  • Warren Buffett Steps Down as Berkshire Hathaway Chairman After 50 Years
  • Pakistan Mosque Bombings Kill Dozens Near Police Facilities
  • Trump Administration Approves $24.3B F-35 Sale to Saudi Arabia Amid Houthi Attacks
  • Trump's Midterm Prospects Dim Amid Low Approval and Voter Frustration
  • Police Move Migrants from Ceuta Beach Camps; Spain Shows Solidarity
  • Trump Faces Criticism Over Kennedy Center Demolition Threat and Other Grievances
  • F-16 Fighter Jet Crashes in Michigan; Pilot Ejects Safely